Tap to get financing
CMBS Loans
Property types
Mobile Home Park CMBS LoansHospital CMBS LoansIndustrial CMBS LoansHotel CMBS LoansRetail CMBS LoansSelf-Storage CMBS LoansMixed-Use CMBS LoansOffice CMBS LoansApartment CMBS LoansCMBS Property Types
Loan basics Loan terms
Resources
BlogCommercial InsuranceLoan Documents
For Brokers
About
TeamLeadership
(561) 556-2121
Get financing →
Newly Published
Jul 3 at CMBS Loans
Business Interruption Insurance for CMBS-Financed Properties
Jul 3 at CMBS Loans
Liability Insurance for CMBS-Financed Commercial Properties
Jul 1 at CMBS Loans
Property Insurance for CMBS-Backed Commercial Real Estate
Explore the Janover Network
May 8 at HUD Loans
The 2025 Developer's Guide to HUD Lender Matching
Apr 22 at Janover Inc. Investor Relations
Janover Inc. Announces Corporate Name Change to DeFi Development Corporation
Apr 16 at Janover Inc. Investor Relations
Janover Inc. to Host X Spaces Conversation on NAV Premiums
Was This Article Helpful?
CMBS Loan Secrets
2 min read

Why CMBS Risk Retention Rules Are Reducing The Amount of Conduit Lenders

While conduit loan issuances have risen steeply in the last few years, the amount of lenders has actually fallen slightly— and experts believe that’s a direct result of a new federal risk retention rule that took effect in Dec. 2016. Before the market crash of 2008, the CMBS market was incredibly hot, and lenders were quite liberal with who they provided loans to— especially because they knew they could transfer 100% of the risk to CMBS bondholders.

Start Your Application and Unlock the Power of Choice Experience expert guidance, competitive options, and unparalleled industry expertise.
Click Here to Get Quotes →
$5.6M offered by a Bank$1.2M offered by a Bank$2M offered by an Agency$1.4M offered by a Credit UnionClick Here to Get Quotes!

New Rules Require Lenders to Keep at Least 5% Of Loans on Their Balance Sheets

While conduit loan issuances have risen steeply in the last few years, the amount of lenders has actually fallen slightly— and experts believe that’s a direct result of new federal risk retention rules that took effect in Dec. 2016. Before the market crash of 2008, the CMBS market was incredibly hot, and lenders were quite liberal with who they provided loans to— especially because they knew they could transfer 100% of the risk to CMBS bondholders.

Two years after the crash, congress passed the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010, which, among other things, was intended to insure that banks had more skin in the game when it came to CMBS loan transactions. To do that, Dodd-Frank mandated that lenders keep 5 percent of the risk for at least 5 years. While Dodd-Frank was passed back in 2010, the rule was issued with a 6-year waiting period, which is why it didn’t go into effect until late 2016.

While these rules may be good for investors, they aren’t the greatest for CMBS borrowers. Since banks and other conduit lenders can now suffer direct losses as a result of CMBS loan defaults, they are likely to tighten underwriting standards, issue less interest-only CMBS loans, and perhaps issue less conduit loans to riskier asset classes, such as student housing properties.

Related Questions

What is CMBS risk retention?

CMBS risk retention is a rule instituted by the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 and first enforced in 2016. It dictates that lenders must hold onto at least 5% of the commercial mortgage-backed securities they issue, including a portion of the B-piece tranches. This rule was implemented to ensure that CMBS lenders' interests remain aligned with the interests of the investors, and to effectively steer them away from offering loans to investors who may turn out to be unable to pay them back.

Sources:

  • Understanding CMBS Tranches
  • Why CMBS Risk Retention Rules Are Reducing The Amount of Conduit Lenders
  • What is a CMBS B-Piece?

How do CMBS risk retention rules affect conduit lenders?

CMBS risk retention rules, instituted by the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 and first enforced in 2016, require lenders to keep at least 5% of the risk for at least 5 years. This means that conduit lenders can suffer direct losses as a result of CMBS loan defaults, so they are likely to tighten underwriting standards, issue less interest-only CMBS loans, and perhaps issue less conduit loans to riskier asset classes, such as student housing properties.

Sources:

  • cmbs.loans/blog/cmbs-risk-retention
  • www.multifamily.loans/apartment-finance-blog/understanding-cmbs-tranches
  • www.multifamily.loans/apartment-finance-blog/the-pros-and-cons-cmbs-of-cmbs-loans-a-guide

What are the benefits of CMBS risk retention rules?

The CMBS risk retention rules instituted by the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 and first enforced in 2016 have several benefits. These rules dictate that lenders must hold onto at least 5% of the commercial mortgage-backed securities they issue, including a portion of the B-piece tranches. This ensures that CMBS lenders' interests remain aligned with the interests of the investors, and effectively steers them away from offering loans to investors who may turn out to be unable to pay them back. This helps to reduce the risk of a CMBS market crisis, like the one that occurred in 2008-2010.

The rules also require that B-piece buyers hold onto their investment for a minimum of 5 years, which means that hedge funds and other players who were actively trading B-piece securities can no longer do so. This helps to reduce the amount of conduit lenders, as they can now suffer direct losses as a result of CMBS loan defaults.

What are the drawbacks of CMBS risk retention rules?

The major drawback of CMBS risk retention rules is that they require lenders to keep at least 5% of the commercial mortgage-backed securities they issue, including a portion of the B-piece tranches. This means that lenders have more skin in the game when it comes to CMBS loan transactions, and as a result, they are likely to tighten underwriting standards, issue less interest-only CMBS loans, and perhaps issue less conduit loans to riskier asset classes, such as student housing properties. Additionally, CMBS loans typically do not permit secondary/supplemental financing, as this is seen to increase the risk for CMBS investors. Finally, most CMBS loans require borrowers to have reserves, including replacement reserves, and money set aside for insurance, taxes, and other essential purposes.

How can borrowers benefit from CMBS risk retention rules?

Borrowers can benefit from CMBS risk retention rules by having lenders' interests remain aligned with the interests of the investors. This helps to ensure that CMBS lenders are not offering loans to investors who may turn out to be unable to pay them back. Additionally, the rules require lenders to keep at least 5% of the commercial mortgage-backed securities they issue, including a portion of the B-piece tranches, on their balance sheets. This helps to reduce the amount of conduit lenders, as they can suffer direct losses as a result of CMBS loan defaults.

Sources:

  • Understanding CMBS Tranches
  • Why CMBS Risk Retention Rules Are Reducing The Amount of Conduit Lenders
  • The Pros and Cons of CMBS Loans: A Guide
In this article:
  1. New Rules Require Lenders to Keep at Least 5% Of Loans on Their Balance Sheets
  2. Related Questions
  3. Get Financing
Categories
  • CMBS Loans
  • Conduit Loans
Tags
  • CMBS Loans
  • Conduit Loans
  • Conduit Financing
  • CMBS Financing
  • CMBS Special Purpose Entities
  • CMBS SPE

Getting commercial property financing should be easy.⁠ Now it is.

Click below for a free, no obligation quote and to learn more about your loan options.

Get financing →

Janover: Your Partner in Growth

At Janover, we offer a wide range of services tailored to your unique needs. From commercial property loans and LP management to business loans and services for lenders, we're here to help you succeed.

Learn more about Janover →
Commercial Property Loans

Get the best CRE financing on the market.

Explore Financing Options →
LP Management

Syndicate deals on autopilot with Janover Connect.

Discover LP Management →
Business Loans

Match with the right kind of loan, in record time.

Find Business Loans →
For Lenders

Supercharge your loan pipeline. Unlock more deals.

Boost Your Loan Pipeline →
CMBS Loans

CMBS Loans is a Janover company. Please visit some of our family of sites at: Multifamily Loans, Commercial Real Estate Loans, SBA7a Loans, HUD Loans, Janover Insurance, Janover Pro, Janover Connect, and Janover Engage.

Janover Tech Inc.

6401 Congress Ave
Ste 250
Boca Raton FL 33487
(561) 556-2121 
hello@cmbs.loans

Property types

Mobile Home Park CMBS Loans
Hospital CMBS Loans
Industrial CMBS Loans
Hotel CMBS Loans
Retail CMBS Loans
Commercial Mortgage Calculator
For Commercial Mortgage Brokers

Self-Storage CMBS Loans
Mixed-Use CMBS Loans
Office CMBS Loans
Apartment CMBS Loans
CMBS Property Types
Commercial Loan Rates
For Commercial Mortgage Brokers

Site Information

Privacy Policy
Terms of Use


For Commercial Mortgage Brokers

This website is owned by a company that offers business advice, information and other services related to multifamily, commercial real estate, and business financing. We have no affiliation with any government agency and are not a lender. We are a technology company that uses software and experience to bring lenders and borrowers together. By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies, our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy. We use cookies to provide you with a great experience and to help our website run effectively.

Freddie Mac® and Optigo® are registered trademarks of Freddie Mac. Fannie Mae® is a registered trademark of Fannie Mae. We are not affiliated with the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), Federal Housing Administration (FHA), Freddie Mac or Fannie Mae.

This website utilizes artificial intelligence technologies to auto-generate responses, which have limitations in accuracy and appropriateness. Users should not rely upon AI-generated content for definitive advice and instead should confirm facts or consult professionals regarding any personal, legal, financial or other matters. The website owner is not responsible for damages allegedly arising from use of this website's AI.

Copyright © 2025 Janover Tech Inc. All rights reserved.

+

Fill out the form below and get the pricing and terms banks can't compete with.